How Reliable Are Your Smartwatch’s Health Stats?

Kunal Kalra - profile photo
By - Published
How Reliable Are Your Smartwatch’s Health Stats?

Wearable technologies have become an integral part of daily life for many Australians, with smartwatches leading the charge. According to the Telsyte Australian Smartphone & Wearable Devices Market Study 2023, 36% of Australians now own a smartwatch—a figure that has grown by 4% in just a year. As these devices become more sophisticated, integrating health, fitness, and connectivity features, their role in our lives has expanded significantly. But with this growth comes an important question: just how accurate are these devices in monitoring our health?

The Popularity of Wearables in Australia

Australians are among the most enthusiastic adopters of wearable technologies, particularly smartwatches. These devices have evolved beyond simple fitness trackers to become essential tools for many users. Whether it’s monitoring heart rate, tracking sleep patterns, or measuring physical activity, smartwatches are now a common sight on Australian wrists.

As tech analyst firm Global Data notes, the popularity of smartwatches has soared as they’ve matured into multifunctional devices. They are not just gadgets but are becoming critical components of the broader mobile ecosystem. This trend is expected to continue, with new forms of wearable technology on the horizon.

What the Research Says

A recent comprehensive review published in Sports Medicine took a deep dive into the accuracy of these wearable devices, particularly focusing on how well they measure key physiological outcomes. The review analysed 24 systematic reviews encompassing 249 validation studies and involving over 430,000 participants. Here’s what the findings revealed:

  • Heart Rate Monitoring: Wearables showed a relatively small margin of error, with a mean bias of ±3%. For most users, this means that heart rate data from wearables is fairly reliable.

  • Arrhythmia Detection: In this area, the devices performed exceptionally well, with a pooled sensitivity and specificity of 100% and 95%, respectively, making them effective at detecting irregular heart rhythms.

  • VO2max Estimation: Wearables were less accurate in estimating VO2max, overestimating it by ±15.24% during resting tests and ±9.83% during exercise tests.

  • Physical Activity Intensity: The accuracy of wearables in measuring physical activity intensity varied widely, with a mean absolute error ranging from 29% to 80%, depending on the activity level.

  • Step Counts and Energy Expenditure: Wearables tended to underestimate step counts, with errors ranging from -9% to +12%. Energy expenditure was also underestimated by an average of 3%, with a wider error margin of -21.27% to 14.76%.

  • Blood Oxygen Saturation: The devices were reasonably accurate in measuring blood oxygen levels, with a mean absolute difference of up to 2.0%.

  • Sleep Monitoring: Wearables were found to overestimate total sleep time by more than 10%, which might not be a major concern for casual users but could affect those relying on these devices for detailed sleep analysis.

The Need for Standardisation

The review highlighted a significant issue: the lack of standardised validation protocols across different studies and devices. This variability makes it difficult to draw definitive conclusions about the overall accuracy of wearables. To improve the reliability of these devices, more collaborative efforts between researchers, manufacturers, and healthcare professionals are needed.

Closing Summary

For Australians who rely on wearables to monitor their health, this research offers valuable insights. While these devices show great potential, their accuracy is not yet at a level where they can fully replace traditional medical assessments. However, they remain useful tools for gaining insights into one’s health and encouraging an active lifestyle. As wearable technology continues to evolve, we can expect these devices to become even more reliable.

For now, it’s important to view wearables as a complement to, rather than a replacement for, professional healthcare monitoring. As these devices become more integrated with other emerging technologies, they may offer even more personalised and intuitive experiences, further embedding themselves into our daily lives.

Suggested articles

Physical Inactivity Costs Western Sydney $1.5 Billion Annually

Physical Inactivity Costs Western Sydney $1.5 Billion Annually

1 month ago

Western Sydney faces a $1.5 billion annual burden due to physical inactivity, leading to rising health risks like diabetes and cardiovascular disease. Addressing barriers such as poor infrastructure and socioeconomic challenges is crucial for creating a healthier, more active community.

Move More, Worry Less: How Exercise Can Help Reduce Dementia Risk

Move More, Worry Less: How Exercise Can Help Reduce Dementia Risk

1 month ago

Did you know that even small amounts of exercise can lower your risk of dementia? A new study reveals that just 30 extra minutes of movement per week can help, no matter your fitness level. Learn how staying active can protect your brain and keep you healthier as you age.

Jump Your Way to Better Fitness: The Benefits of High-Intensity Interval Rope Skipping

Jump Your Way to Better Fitness: The Benefits of High-Intensity Interval Rope Skipping

1 month ago

Skipping rope isn’t just for kids—it’s a powerful workout that improves fitness, heart health, and endurance. A recent study reveals how high-intensity and moderate-intensity skipping can deliver the same fitness benefits, making it a fun and efficient exercise for all.

Free 3×3 Basketball and Pickleball Court Pops Up in Perth CBD for Summer

Free 3×3 Basketball and Pickleball Court Pops Up in Perth CBD for Summer

1 month ago

Get ready for Brookfield Place’s Summer of Sports in Perth! From 27 January to 28 March, enjoy free 3×3 basketball and pickleball in a vibrant city setting. A perfect way to stay active, socialise, and embrace the summer vibes. Reserve your spot now!

Keep Your New Year’s Fitness Resolution: Make It Fun,
Easy, and Realistic

Keep Your New Year’s Fitness Resolution: Make It Fun, Easy, and Realistic

1 month ago

Inspired by a recent episode of The Vergecast, here are tips on how to keep your New Year's fitness resolution. From starting small to finding fun activities and breaking streaks, these ideas focus on making fitness easy and rewarding.

Looking to get active?

Here is a few options to explore: